Since Notifuse 43, each contact can agree to or refuse open tracking and click tracking separately. Their choice decides what goes into every email you send them, and it still applies after the email has left.
We built it because two European regulators said this year that the open pixel is a tracker like any other. If you send to people in France or Italy, open tracking now needs their consent in most cases. Here is what the regulators ask for, how Notifuse handles it, and what you need to set up.
What changed
A tracking pixel is a tiny image, unique to each recipient, that the mail client downloads when the email is opened. The request tells the sender who opened the email, and when. In 2024, the European Data Protection Board confirmed that this falls under the ePrivacy rule on reading information from a user's device, the same rule as cookies. Two national regulators then spelled out what that means for email:
In France, the CNIL adopted its recommendation on tracking pixels in emails on 12 March 2026 and published it in April. Senders had three months to inform the people already on their lists.
In Italy, the Garante adopted its guidelines on tracking pixels on 17 April 2026. They were published in the Gazzetta Ufficiale on 29 April, with six months to comply, so until the end of October.
Both deadlines have passed. The two texts make these points:
Measuring each recipient's opens needs their prior consent. That covers open rates used to improve your campaigns, profiles built from what people open, and fraud detection. The CNIL lists a few exemptions, all narrow: authentication security, and deliverability measurement strictly limited to spotting inactive recipients, for emails the recipient asked for, such as transactional emails. The Garante also exempts aggregate statistics, as long as they can't measure what each recipient did.
The CNIL points out that tracked links fall under the same article of the law as pixels, which is why Notifuse treats clicks as a separate choice.
Refusing has to be as easy as agreeing. The CNIL recommends a link in the footer of every email that withdraws consent with no further step, and in particular without typing an email address. The Garante asks that recipients can keep receiving your emails without pixels, rather than having to unsubscribe.
A withdrawal must also cover emails already sent: when someone re-opens an old email after refusing, the open must not be recorded.
A machine must not be able to set off a consent link. Some mail clients and security scanners open links on their own, so the CNIL recommends that the link lead to a page where the person confirms with a click.
The CNIL treats a recipient's silence as a refusal, and asks senders to keep proof of each consent.
The rules differ in the details. The Garante, for example, lets you collect tracking consent together with consent to marketing emails. The CNIL recommends a separate consent for each purpose, and allows a single one only for the tracking that serves the marketing itself, such as personalizing it. None of this is legal advice: read the texts, and ask your DPO which ones apply to you.
Two switches
In the Email tracking panel of Settings → General, open tracking and click tracking now have a switch each. When one is off, no email carries it.
A third setting, Contacts without recorded consent, decides what happens for the contacts who never made a choice: Track or Don't track. Track is the default, so nothing changes when you upgrade. If the CNIL or the Garante applies to you, choose Don't track: only the contacts who agreed are then tracked, which matches how the CNIL reads a recipient's silence.
Consent with proof
Each contact has four new fields:
tracking_opens_consentandtracking_clicks_consent:granted,denied, or empty when the contact never chose.tracking_consent_updated_at: when the choice last changed.tracking_consent_source: where it came from (your signup form, the API, a CSV import, the console, the notification center or the opt-out link of an email).
A contact's own choice always wins over the workspace default. You can collect it where the CNIL recommends, on the form where you collect the email address, by sending the two fields with the subscription. The API and imports can set it too. You can filter contacts and build segments on it, start an automation when it changes, and receive it in your contact webhooks.
Opt-out link
Two new template variables let a contact choose from the email itself:
{{ tracking_optout_url }}refuses both open and click tracking. It opens a page that asks the contact to confirm, so a security scanner that follows the link changes nothing.{{ tracking_preferences_url }}opens a dialog where the contact allows or stops opens and clicks separately.
Both links are signed for their recipient, so the contact never types an email address, and nobody else can change that contact's choice. They are never rewritten for tracking. The notification center, the page behind your unsubscribe and preferences links, now also says whether tracking is on for the contact and offers the same dialog.
Put one of them in the footer of your templates, next to the unsubscribe link:
<a href="{{ tracking_optout_url }}">Don't track my opens and clicks</a>Past emails too
Notifuse checks the contact's choice twice. When the email is sent, a contact who refused gets no open pixel, or no tracked links. When an open or a click comes in later, Notifuse checks again. If the contact has refused in the meantime, nothing is recorded, and the link still takes them to the page.
Never tracked
Some emails shouldn't carry tracking, whoever receives them: a notice that you are changing your terms, or the email that asks your existing contacts for their consent. The CNIL says that email must itself contain no tracker that needs consent.
A broadcast can now be sent without open and click tracking, and keeps its UTM parameters, so your web analytics still sees where visits came from.
A transactional notification can do the same, or turn tracking off entirely, UTM parameters included, for links that must stay as written, such as sign-in links.
Honest open rates
Once some contacts aren't tracked, the usual open rate becomes wrong. Divide the opens by every email sent, and an untracked email looks like an email nobody opened. A campaign sent mostly to contacts who refused would look like a failure.
So Notifuse now counts open and click rates over the emails that were tracked. That applies to broadcast statistics, A/B test results, per-link click rates and the analytics dashboard. When some emails weren't tracked, the rate's tooltip says how many were (of 1,200 tracked), and a rate with no tracked email shows a dash instead of 0%. The rates of transactional notifications and of automation email steps are counted the same way.
A/B tests follow the same rule. The automatic winner is chosen on the tracked recipients of each variation. If none of them was tracked, you pick the winner yourself, and the variations table warns you when fewer than half of a variation's recipients were tracked. Emails sent before version 43 count as tracked, so your past rates don't move.
Setup
Upgrade to Notifuse 43 or later. The migration adds the consent fields. Nothing changes for your contacts until you change the settings.
Choose your default in Settings → General, and pick Don't track if the CNIL or the Garante applies to you.
Ask at signup: add an unticked box for tracking to your subscription form, explain in a sentence what it measures, and send
tracking_opens_consentandtracking_clicks_consentwith the subscription.Add the refusal link to the footer of your templates.
Ask the contacts you already have by sending them a broadcast without tracking that links to
{{ tracking_preferences_url }}. That is the method the CNIL describes for addresses collected without that consent. The CNIL also suggests not asking again for six months after someone answers. A segment ontracking_consent_updated_athandles that.Review your transactional notifications one by one, and turn tracking off on the ones that don't need it.
Not yet
The CNIL exempts open measurement used only to spot inactive recipients, provided you keep no more than the date of the last open. Notifuse has no such deliverability-only mode: a contact who isn't tracked is simply not tracked, so you lose their opens, and with them the inactive-contact cleanup based on opens.
Contacts make one choice for opens and one for clicks, while the CNIL lists several purposes for opens: campaign performance, profiling, fraud detection. If you need to ask for each purpose separately, you'll have to record those choices yourself, in custom fields for example.
As proof, Notifuse records when the choice changed and where it came from. It doesn't store the wording your form showed at the time, so keep each version of that text yourself.
All the details are in the email tracking documentation. If a regulator in your country asks for something Notifuse doesn't support yet, open an issue and point us to the text.
